7 Best Thordata Alternatives in 2026
Your scraper broke at 3 AM again. The IPs were supposed to be US residential, but half resolved to Southeast Asia. Support ticket? Still open from last week.
Thordata does a lot right - one Reddit user tested it for $5 and called the quality "actually impressive," and you can run a Google Maps scraping setup for $10-15/month. But geo-mismatch issues, slow support, and billing surprises push people to look elsewhere. We spent weeks testing alternatives and digging through community threads to find what actually holds up.
Our Picks (TL;DR)
At roughly 25GB/month of residential bandwidth:
| Provider | Best For | Residential $/GB | Pool Size | Free Trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decodo | Overall balance | $3.25/GB | 115M+ IPs | 3-day, 100MB |
| Oxylabs | Enterprise scale | $4.00/GB | 175M+ IPs | Custom |
| Prospeo | B2B contact data | ~$0.01/lead | 300M+ profiles | Free tier |
| Rayobyte | Non-expiring BW | $3.50/GB | 40M+ IPs | PAYG |
| Bright Data | Feature depth | $4.00/GB (PAYG) | 72M+ IPs | 7-day |
Success rates sourced from [Proxyway's 2M+ request benchmark](https://proxyway.com/research/proxy-market-research-2024) and [AIMultiple's load tests](https://aimultiple.com/residential-proxy-providers).
Best Proxy Providers to Replace Thordata
Decodo
Use this if you want Oxylabs-level performance without the enterprise price tag. Skip this if you need the absolute biggest pool and price isn't a concern.
Decodo hit a 99.86% success rate with 0.63s average response time in Proxyway's benchmark - one of the strongest results on raw reliability. The pool runs 115M+ IPs across 195+ locations with targeting down to ZIP and ASN level.
The pricing ladder scales nicely: $3.50/GB at 10GB, $3.25/GB at 25GB, dropping to $2.00/GB at 1TB. PAYG runs $4.00/GB with no commitment. There's a 3-day free trial with 100MB and a 14-day money-back guarantee, so you can actually test before committing real budget.
In our experience, this is the sweet spot for most teams - Oxylabs-level performance at around 19% less per GB.
Oxylabs
Use this if you need the deepest IP pool and ZIP-level geo-targeting for enterprise-scale scraping. Skip this if you're trying to stay on a tight monthly budget.
Oxylabs is the enterprise standard. CNET names it "[best for larger businesses](https://www.cnet.com/tech/services-and-software/oxylabs-review/)" and the numbers back it up: 175M+ residential IPs, 195+ countries, 10,400+ cities. Proxyway clocked it at 99.82% success rate with the fastest response time in their benchmark - 0.41 seconds.
Residential runs $4.00/GB, and enterprise contracts typically land in the $500-$2,000+/month range depending on volume. You're paying a premium for the deepest pool and fastest responses. For teams scraping at scale across dozens of geos, that premium pays for itself in fewer retries and cleaner data.
Bright Data
Bright Data packs the most features of any provider on this list: residential, datacenter, mobile, ISP proxies plus Web Unlocker, Scraping Browser, and a Web MCP free tier giving you 5,000 requests/month for AI agents. Residential runs $4.00/GB on PAYG or about $3.57/GB on a $499/month bundle. Mobile sits at $8.00/GB.
The downside? More plan permutations than most teams want to evaluate. The 7-day free trial requires company registration. If you just need residential proxies, you're paying for features you won't touch.
Rayobyte
Use this if your scraping is bursty - big jobs one week, nothing the next. Skip this if you need the highest success rates on heavily protected targets.
Rayobyte's killer feature: bandwidth never expires. Their FAQ literally says "It's yours 'til the heat-death of the universe." Pricing starts at $3.50/GB for 1-49GB and drops aggressively - $2.00/GB at 50GB, down to $0.50/GB at 5TB+. The pool is 40M+ IPs across 163+ locations.
Best option if you buy in bursts and hate watching unused credits expire at month-end. IPRoyal offers a similar non-expiring model at comparable rates if you want a second provider to benchmark against.
Webshare
Budget pick. CNET lists Webshare residential at $3.50/GB with an 80M IP pool and 10 free proxies - no credit card required. CNET flags it as more likely to be detected on protected targets, so don't expect Decodo-level success rates. Fine for low-stakes scraping where cost matters more than stealth.
NetNut
Starts at $99/month for 28GB ($3.53/GB) with no micro-packages or PAYG option. The trial requires a WhatsApp call with sales before you get 1GB for 24 hours. Look - if a proxy provider won't let you test without a sales call in 2026, that tells you who they're optimizing for, and it isn't individual developers or small teams.
You're spending $3-4/GB on residential proxies, plus engineering hours to maintain scrapers that break every time a site updates its markup. Prospeo gives you 300M+ profiles with 98% email accuracy and 125M+ verified mobiles - no proxy stack, no parsing, no 3 AM scraper fires.
Replace your entire scraping stack with one search. 75 free emails to prove it.
When You Don't Need a Proxy at All
Here's the thing: if you're running proxies specifically to scrape B2B contact data - emails, phone numbers, company info - you're overengineering the problem. Building and maintaining a proxy + scraper + parser stack costs $100-300/month before you count the engineering time to keep it running when sites change their markup.
If you're doing web scraping lead generation, it's worth sanity-checking whether you even need a proxy layer for the outcome you want.
Prospeo eliminates that entire stack. It's a B2B data platform with 300M+ professional profiles, 143M+ verified emails, and 125M+ verified mobile numbers, all searchable through 30+ filters including buyer intent, technographics, job changes, and funding signals. Email accuracy sits at 98% with a 7-day data refresh cycle - roughly six times faster than the industry average.
The cost math is straightforward: roughly $0.01 per lead. A free tier gives you 75 emails per month to test. No contracts, no sales calls, self-serve onboarding. We've seen teams spend weeks building scraping infrastructure for lead gen when they could've had verified contacts in minutes.
If your real goal is lead enrichment (not just raw scraping), a data platform can be the simpler path.
Proxy providers refresh IP pools. Prospeo refreshes 300M+ contact records every 7 days - 6x faster than the industry average. If your Thordata alternative search is really about getting accurate B2B leads, skip the middleman. Verified emails at $0.01 each, no bandwidth math required.
Ditch the proxy-scraper-parser chain. Get verified contacts in seconds.
How to Choose the Right Provider
Check IP reputation, not just pool size. One Reddit user spent $500 testing providers and found that cheap "unlimited" plans around $50/month performed worst - blacklisted IPs and low concurrency killed success rates. Recycled or flagged IPs tank your results regardless of how many millions the provider advertises.
If you're using proxies to build outbound lists, you may be better served by a sales prospecting database instead of scraping.
Normalize pricing at 25GB/month. Per-GB rates vary wildly by tier. Comparing Decodo at 10GB ($3.50/GB) against Rayobyte at 250GB ($1.50/GB) isn't apples-to-apples. In our testing, normalizing at 25GB gave the most accurate comparison across providers.
If you're comparing proxy spend to data spend, it helps to benchmark against B2B company data providers too.
Test 2-3 providers, not 10. Pick one premium option like Decodo or Oxylabs and one value option like Rayobyte or Webshare, then run them against your actual targets for a week. Self-serve trials like Decodo's 3-day window and Webshare's free proxies tell you more in an hour than a sales-gated demo ever will. The consensus on r/WebDataDiggers backs this up - real-world testing on your specific targets matters more than any benchmark.
If your end game is outreach, pair testing with a plan for how to generate an email list and a few sales prospecting techniques that don’t rely on brittle scrapers.
FAQ
Is Thordata legit?
Yes. Reddit users confirm residential IPs trace to Tier-1 ISPs, and the SERP API handles CAPTCHA bypass and JS rendering reliably. The main complaints are slow support and occasional geo-mismatch on specific country targets, not fraud or fake IPs.
What's the cheapest alternative?
Webshare and Rayobyte both start at $3.50/GB for residential proxies. Webshare offers 10 free proxies with no credit card. Rayobyte's bandwidth never expires, which saves money if your usage is inconsistent month to month.
What if I just need B2B contact data?
Skip proxies entirely. Prospeo gives you 143M+ verified emails and 125M+ mobile numbers from 300M+ profiles - no scraping required. The free tier includes 75 emails per month so you can test data quality before committing.